Coaching

The six things missing before you ever open a rubric

By Chad T Dyar 3 min read

The six things missing before you ever open a rubric I handed a manager a scorecard once, first day of a coaching rollout, and she looked at it for a long moment before she looked at me and asked what a four actually...

The six things missing before you ever open a rubric

I handed a manager a scorecard once, first day of a coaching rollout, and she looked at it for a long moment before she looked at me and asked what a four actually sounded like on a call. I did not have an answer. The scorecard had numbers on it, and numbers are not the same thing as a definition.

I built that same coaching program four different times at four different companies over about a decade, and every time I threw out most of what I had built before. The parts that survived were never the rubric itself. They were six questions I had learned to ask before I ever wrote one line of a scorecard, and I only noticed they were the same six questions after the fourth time, when I finally wrote them down instead of trusting myself to remember.

Definition. What does good sound like, in this motion, on this kind of call, said out loud in words two managers would agree on. Most programs skip straight to scoring without ever settling this, so every score ends up a manager's mood wearing a number.

Evidence. Where does the score come from. A gut read from memory is not evidence. A library of real clips tied to real moments on real calls is evidence, and it has to come from your own calls, because a vendor's generic rubric was never trained on your motion.

Cadence. How often coaching actually happens, not how often it is supposed to happen. I have watched beautifully designed programs die quietly in the first bad quarter, because the manager's coaching time was an intention and the deal review was a commitment. Only one of those survives a hard month.

Capability. Whether the manager can actually coach, separate from whether they can sell. Plenty of great reps get promoted into management and handed a scorecard with no instruction on how to use it in a real conversation. The scorecard is not the skill, and assuming the promotion comes with the skill built in is a coin flip most programs lose.

Verification. Whether the coaching changed anything, three weeks later, on the next call. Most programs measure whether coaching happened. Almost none measure whether it worked, and those turn out to be two different questions with two different answers.

Governance. Who owns this program when the person who built it moves on. A program that lives in one person's head is a habit, not a system, and habits end the day that person leaves the room.

Six questions, and I rebuilt around all six for close to ten years before I noticed the pattern. The company changed every time. The product changed every time. The six questions never did. The one build where all six were actually in place together produced a 34 percent lift in quota attainment for reps who certified in the methodology, and cut new rep ramp time from six months to under four.

I turned them into a short assessment, twenty four points across the six dimensions, about four minutes, because I got tired of watching people find this out the hard way the same way I did, one failed rollout at a time. It scores where you stand and names your weakest dimension, which is usually the one nobody in the room wants to say out loud first.

Free, no pitch attached. Score yours before you write another rubric: chadtdyar.com/coaching-score.

Back to Blog | Home