Personal Development

The Choice a Five-Year-Old Makes Every Day (and Can't Explain)

By Chad T Dyar 4 min read

Dolly stood at the edge of the yard for a full minute before she decided anything. My mother's dog, visiting for the week, watching the other two dogs already tangled up in a game she hadn't been invited into by name....

Dolly stood at the edge of the yard for a full minute before she decided anything. My mother's dog, visiting for the week, watching the other two dogs already tangled up in a game she hadn't been invited into by name. She could have barreled in. She could have turned around and found something to do alone. Instead she just stood there, doing the thing none of us teach kids how to do on purpose: deciding, in real time, whether to join in.

There was no dramatic conflict in that minute and no clear lesson sitting at the end of it, only a decision that had to get made with information that was never going to be complete. The Sparkle, the Snuggle, and the Song came out of watching a dog make a call that a five-year-old has to make a dozen times a day, usually with less warning and higher stakes, usually right after an adult has told her to simply "share" or "be kind" with no actual picture of what that looks like in the moment.

Why relationship skills is the hard one

CASEL calls this competency Relationship Skills, and it's the one I think gets the least credit for being difficult. Self-awareness is about knowing your own feeling. Relationship skills asks a kid to track somebody else's feeling, read a room that isn't about her, and decide what to do with information she's only guessing at. Dolly didn't know if the game had room for her. She didn't know if joining would be welcome or would wreck something already working. She had to decide anyway, with incomplete information, the same way every kid at a playground or a lunch table has to.

Maya Rudolph, my fluffy mini Australian Shepherd with what might be the happiest face of any dog I've ever met, is the one who actually leads this story. She's the one deciding in the moment whether to pull Dolly in or let her find her own way, and that choice, not Dolly's hesitation, is the real center of the book. Relationship skills is just as much about the kids already in the game deciding how to make room as it is about the kid standing at the edge wondering whether to join.

What "share" and "be kind" actually skip over

Telling a kid to share skips the entire decision that happens before sharing: noticing someone wants in, caring whether they get in, and figuring out how to make that happen without wrecking what's already working. Telling a kid to be kind skips the same gap from the other direction. Kindness works as a sequence: notice, care, act, and most instruction skips straight from notice to act like caring in between happens automatically.

A five-year-old standing at the edge of a game, or sitting alone at a lunch table, isn't missing the instruction to "go say hi." She's missing practice at the noticing and the caring that has to happen first, the part that doesn't come with a script.

What this looks like outside the book

For a parent or teacher, the useful move isn't telling a kid what to do in the moment. It's narrating the decision itself, out loud, after the fact when nobody's upset: "I saw you notice that Sam was standing by himself. What were you thinking right before you went over?" That question treats the noticing and the deciding as a skill worth naming, not an obvious thing every kid should already have.

The same goes the other direction. A kid who's already in the game, like Maya Rudolph deciding whether to make room for Dolly, is practicing relationship skills just as much as the kid on the outside. Asking "how did you know she wanted to join?" teaches a kid to pay attention to signals she might otherwise miss entirely.

The part I didn't expect

I built this series around watching real dogs, and I didn't expect the hardest competency to map to would be the one with the gentlest-looking moment: a dog standing at the edge of a yard for sixty seconds with a decision that had to get made anyway. Deciding anyway, with information that was never going to be complete, is most of what relationship skills actually is, for a five-year-old or for anyone.

The Sparkle, the Snuggle, and the Song is the third book in the Heart Dog series, and like the other four, it's built to be read with a kid rather than just to one, since most of the actual teaching happens in the conversation after the last page, not in the page itself.

Back to Blog | Home